explosivecombat: (Someone needs to listen more carefully)
Solf J Kimblee ([personal profile] explosivecombat) wrote2014-07-09 07:37 pm

035. [ANON TEXT]

[Well, good evening, network - it seems Seth's device is active again, though at the very least he's not inviting everyone to war like he's throwing the world's most unasked-for party this time around.]

You know, one of the things I've always found most fascinating about human morality is the idea that we're higher beings due to our natural inclination to put others before ourselves. It's generally accepted in society that we should be willing to sacrifice ourselves before harming another; I've always found adhering to that sort of notion to both vaguely admirable and sickeningly saccharine. If you must kill one to save another, that's still a life that's lost; why shouldn't the reward go to the one who's willing to fight for it, rather than the one who did nothing to earn it but sit there in pious devotion to doing nothing wrong?

We claim superiority for suppressing our instincts to survive; if anything, I think that would put us lower than dogs, not above them. All this intelligence and no will to live; it's pitiful.

But then, I suppose my lack of understanding of these things is why I can't be considered one of you.

For the time being, however, say I were to humor you in discussion for a while. Do you think your will to fight to ensure your survival actually needs to be tested? Since I suspect the answer will overwhelmingly be "No," I have another pre-emptive question for the heroic types.

Is there anything outside of arrogance and so-called moral superiority that makes you say so?


[...O...kay that's really not any better but apparently, it's just that kind of night.

You know, full of misanthropy.

Because some nights are like that.]
adnihilum: (attentive)

[personal profile] adnihilum 2014-07-10 01:22 am (UTC)(link)
I don't think it's a necessary question.

Population aggregation is not something humans can control. If it happens, then it does, and the altruism model takes hold. If not, then the instinctual model takes hold. Either way, you survive. Advantageous to self.
adnihilum: (nonchalance)

[personal profile] adnihilum 2014-07-10 01:26 am (UTC)(link)
I don't believe in anything.

Unless you have access to an instrument able to perform population control, then there will be an increase in population density until the maximum load support of the land is reached.

It is an animal instinct to breed, after all.
adnihilum: (discord)

[personal profile] adnihilum 2014-07-10 01:34 am (UTC)(link)
How pretentious of you.

I was merely observing.
adnihilum: (attentive)

[personal profile] adnihilum 2014-07-10 01:44 am (UTC)(link)
Neutral observations and inference from known rules do not imply a need for any moralistic judgment.

As for your stand, I can see where it comes from. But that does not imply I am necessarily going to agree or disagree.

There are different forms of self-interest, after all.


adnihilum: (Default)

[personal profile] adnihilum 2014-07-10 01:50 am (UTC)(link)
When you asked whether reaching the altruistic model should be allowed.
adnihilum: (pensive)

[personal profile] adnihilum 2014-07-10 01:59 am (UTC)(link)
By using the word 'should' you are implying that there is a right and wrong with regards to deciding how others should act, which in turn requires moral judgment.

If you're so insistent on pressing your concept of a belief, then I believe that people should act to maximize their net benefit.
adnihilum: (attentive)

[personal profile] adnihilum 2014-07-10 02:01 am (UTC)(link)
By your definition.

But I do not necessarily believe in forcing my beliefs on others.
adnihilum: (Default)

[personal profile] adnihilum 2014-07-10 02:06 am (UTC)(link)
[ You're the one being hypocritical here. ]

Try not to do it next time.
adnihilum: (Default)

[personal profile] adnihilum 2014-07-10 02:09 am (UTC)(link)
[ And you, Mister EVERY OBSERVATION HAS A MORALISTIC IMPLICATION. ]

Fine by me. I don't have time to put up with people who can't hold up a proper discussion.
adnihilum: (pensive)

[personal profile] adnihilum 2014-07-10 02:11 am (UTC)(link)
Likewise with you.
adnihilum: (well wouldn't you like to know)

[personal profile] adnihilum 2014-07-10 02:20 am (UTC)(link)
[ Likewise with you. Learn how to speak straight for once.

Flynn's run out of social energy, either way. Enjoy your silence. ]